9 Margarets Drive, Shelter Island, NY 11964

$5,250,000
Active for Sale
4 Beds
5.5 Baths
5530 SF
Built In 2022
 
Listing ID 931711
Property Type Residential
Township Shelter Island
Hamlet Shelter Island
Total Tax $14,223
Tax ID 0900-024.000-0001-025.000
FEMA Flood Map fema.gov/portal
Year Built 2022
Associated Documents
Virtual Tour

AIA AWARD-WINNING ARCHITECTURE | LIGHT, LANDSCAPE & DESIGN

An AIA Award-winning design by Lacuna Architecture Atelier, 9 Margarets Drive brings architecture, landscape, and natural light into remarkable harmony. Encompassing approximately 5,530 square feet, including a substantial finished lower level, the home offers four en-suite bedrooms, five full baths, and one half bath, with a design that creates a seamless connection between indoors and out. A soaring, light-filled great room unfolds beneath dramatic vaulted ceilings, where expansive walls of glass dissolve the boundary between interior and exterior spaces. A striking two-sided fireplace anchors the living areas, creating a natural dialogue between the home's architecture and surrounding landscape. At the heart of the residence, a chef's kitchen with top-tier appliances integrates beautifully with the living and dining spaces, equally suited to everyday living and entertaining. Custom white oak millwork and carefully selected finishes reflect the architectural vision of Gregory Thomas, known for exceptional craftsmanship and attention to detail, developed in collaboration with builder Sean Murphy. Each bedroom suite opens directly to the surrounding landscape, further reinforcing the home's connection to nature. Beyond the walls of glass, a 50' x 17' heated saltwater gunite pool anchors the outdoor setting, framed by expansive terraces and multiple lounge and dining areas. A beautifully appointed pool house with a full bath and outdoor shower, together with mature landscaping, creates exceptional privacy while preserving a sense of openness. The result is the ease and privacy of a refined private resort. Situated on a tree-lined street just moments from Shelter Island's beaches, marinas, and restaurants, 9 Margarets Drive offers a rare opportunity to own an architecturally significant residence defined by timeless design, natural beauty, and effortless indoor-outdoor living.
Property Details
  • 4 Total Bedrooms
  • 5 Full Baths
  • 1 Half Bath
  • 5530 SF (Total)
  • 0.91 Acres
  • Built in 2022
  • Available 5/09/2026
  • Modern Style
  • Full Basement
  • Lower Level: Finished
  • Renovation: Beautiful build with ongoing updates.
Interior Features
  • Open Kitchen
  • Oven/Range
  • Refrigerator
  • Dishwasher
  • Microwave
  • Dryer
  • Appliance Hot Water Heater
  • Hardwood Flooring
  • Entry Foyer
  • Living Room
  • Dining Room
  • Family Room
  • Formal Room
  • Den/Office
  • Study
  • Primary Bedroom
  • en Suite Bathroom
  • Walk-in Closet
  • Media Room
  • Bonus Room
  • Great Room
  • Gym
  • Kitchen
  • Breakfast
  • Laundry
  • Private Guestroom
  • First Floor Primary Bedroom
  • First Floor Bathroom
  • 2 Fireplaces
  • Heat Pump
  • 5 Heat/AC Zones
  • Electric Fuel
  • Central A/C
Exterior Features
  • Metal Roof
  • Attached Garage
  • 2 Garage Spaces
  • Private Well Water
  • Private Septic
  • Pool: In Ground, Gunite, Heated, Salt Water
  • Pool Size: 50' x 17'
  • Deck
  • Fence
  • Open Porch
  • Covered Porch
  • Outdoor Shower
  • Cul de Sac
  • Driveway
  • Pool House
  • New Construction
Taxes and Fees
  • $14,223 Total Tax
  • Tax Year 2025
Listed By
Compass
Office: 646-573-9525
Mobile: 646-573-9525
Request More Information
Request Showing
Role Agent Buyer
Your Preferred Date & Time
Showing Type:
Listing data is deemed reliable but is NOT guaranteed accurate.
Contact Us
Who Would You Like to Contact Today?

I want to contact an agent about this property!

I wish to provide feedback about the website functionality

Contact Agent
Your Name:
Email:
Phone:
Message:
Security: What is 7 minus 5?